Salt Lake City is trying to pass an ordinance restricting panhandling in the city. I chose this as my topic for the opinion article because I have some experience with it and I saw a broadcast about it on CNN last week. Being altruistic by nature, I used to want to save everyone I saw out on the streets in dire circumstances. While I lived in Sacramento I invited a homeless woman to live with me, and she did for a week. Plus, there was a transient man I used to see by the train tracks that I made lunch for regularly. I believe in that kind of sacrifice and charity toward all God’s creatures, especially our fellow human beings.
So when I heard about this new law it surprised me that I wanted it passed. I wanted to no longer be bothered by my ‘fellow human beings’. After all, the woman I invited to live with me ended up taking off with my car and the man I made lunch for eventually followed me, making sexual advances, while he was high on something one day. I became disenchanted with the great unwashed of our society at that point. So, out of guilt and curiosity I looked up editorials on the topic.
I chose a Salt Lake Tribune article on the subject. The author came off at the beginning as if he had a snap judgment about panhandlers that I agreed with. Then he turned the tide of the article halfway through, ending with me not agreeing with him. He used Logos, which always speaks to my intellect, and a lot of Pathos without sounding manipulative. He made his point with the grain of the new ordinance and still admitted he was against it at the end without loosing integrity.
Monday, October 12, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment